Profile image for peterjcl

Antony Passage 'Footpath' Public Inquiry resumes at 10am on Wednesday the14th March 2012. At the Eliot Hall, St.Germans.

Peter Clements. Definitive Map of Public Rights of Way Modification Order Applicant.


By peterjcl at 08:08 on 28/02/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    Among the 'proof of evidence' submitted to the Inspector one of the objectors to Cornwall Council's Order (and my application) to modify the Definitive Map of Public Rights of Way has gone to great lengths to show that the slipway at Antony Passage floods with water at High Spring tide. I understand that the argument is that because a part of the route of the path is inundated with water, at that state of the tide, the way cannot be a Public Right of Way.
    A counter argument is that Landulph Public Footpath number 2, along the Tamar River from near Landulph Church to Cargreen, is signposted each end saying: "Public Footpath – only usable at Low Spring Tide". It seems that being inundated with water, along most of its length at most states of tide, does not stop Landulph Public Footpath number 2 from being a Public Right of Way.
    I would appreciate it if anyone could give me examples of other local of Public Rights of Way that flood at various tidal states.
    I also notice that in Section 31(11) of the Highways Act 1980 that "'Land' is defined as including land covered by water". Thus, that section can apply to the acquisition of a right of way through a ford or along a causeway or across a slipway inundated by water at some stage of the tide.
    Or failing that, maybe, it would have been possible for members of the public to take shoes and socks off, roll up trouser, and wade across the slipway?
    Peter Clements.
    Definitive Map Modification Order Applicant.

    By peterjcl at 17:44 on 28/02/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    In their 'Final Statement of Case' the Objectors have produced a letter. (as Attachment 21: available to read but not take away in Reception, Saltash Guildhall.)
    The letter says "apparently there was a challenge to access launched in the 60's at which time the Town Council and other Saltash residents lost their case against [the then owner] and were ordered to pay damages".
    Saltash Borough Council, Works Committee minutes of 29th October 1963 say "The Town Clerk reported the receipt of correspondence from [the then owner] with regard to the alleged infringement of the right of way at Antony Passage. RESOLVED that the Town Clerk instruct Council to settle proceedings to be commenced against the person alleged to have infringed the right of way at Antony Passage." I can find no other report in any Saltash Borough minutes of the outcome of these proceedings and, rightly or wrongly, assumed that the right of way was cleared before proceedings became necessary.
    The Objectors refer to this 'case' in other evidence presented to the Inspector and say that the [owner] won the case and that considerable costs were awarded against Saltash Borough Council.
    I can't find any evidence of, or anyone who has any recollection of, this case other than that of the Objectors and their supporters.
    I have written to the author of the 'attachment 21' letter asking where I too can find any information about this 'case': but, he has not replied.
    If you do know where I can find any evidence of this case please can you tell me? Preferably before the Public Inquiry resumes at 10am on the 14th March 2012: in the Eliot Hall, St. Germans.
    Peter Clements
    Definitive Map Modification Order applicant.

    By peterjcl at 13:06 on 29/02/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    The Public Inquiry has been adjourned again until the 12 September at 10 in Saltash Guildhall.

    By peterjcl at 14:28 on 18/03/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    The Public Inquiry resumes at Saltash Guildhall at 10 on Wednesday 12th September 2012. (It could continue for two days.)

    By peterjcl at 15:12 on 24/08/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    Just a reminder that the Public Inquiry into 'The County of Cornwall (Footpath No.17 to the County Road at Antony Passage, Saltash) Modification Order 2010 ("the Order"))' resumes at 10am on Wednesday 12 September 2012 in Saltash Guildhall.
    Definitive Map Modification Order applicant

    By peterjcl at 11:48 on 06/09/12

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    I've received the Antony Passage path Order Decision

    The first page says "Summary of Decision: The Order is confirmed".

    Page 17 says:
    Conclusions (paragraph) 106.
    "Having regard to all the submission made both in writing and at the inquiry I conclude that, on the balance of probability, a public footpath subsists over the order route, and that the Order should therefore be confirmed."

    (paragraph) 107.
    "I confirm the Order."

    Signed by the Inspector

    An electronic version of all the decision is on the Inspectorate's website at:

    By peterjcl at 16:01 on 01/11/12

  • Profile image for TarmacJunkie

    Well done Peter;

    that will make it an easier route, and now the rains have eased we'll be walking that way again soon!

    By TarmacJunkie at 14:21 on 07/01/13

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    But: I will wait just a little longer before I think I can accept your 'well done'
    Because within 6 weeks of the order being confirmed any person aggrieved by the confirmed order can make an application to challenge the order in the High Court . (I think the 6 weeks ends on 11th January 2013). Then, if such a challenge were successful, the High Court will quash the order.

    By peterjcl at 15:49 on 07/01/13

  • Profile image for peterjcl

    The owner of the Antony Passage Boathouse (Moor3 Ltd) has applied to challenge the Inspector's decision in the High Court

    By peterjcl at 15:39 on 01/02/13


Join the Discussion

max 4000 characters

Local Jobs


Search for...

Min price is bigger than Max price
Min price is bigger than Max price
Min rent is bigger than Max rent